GUEST BLOGGER : UPHILL WRITING

If you’ve read UhW for any length of time you may recall me going on and on (…and on) about the nature of evil.

I have said that most of what we call evil is really something else. What, you ask?

Mostly it is carelessness. Mindlessness. Actions with unintentioned results.

Many people disagree with me. They point to who they consider evil and proclaim, “See? There! Evil PURE AND SIMPLE by way of the Eighth Dimension!”* …or some such.

Folks tell me that Hitler was evil. They say that Pol Pot’s Killing Fields were evil. But then, when they talk about the firebombing of Dresden by the RAF and US Air Force, or the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki we call it a humane way to stop a war that would take even more lives.

Is evil a real thing, or is it just a point of view? Would the perpetrators of war crimes—people who call the actions just, change their minds if they became the target of the same fate if they were judged? I think they would. Evil is in the eye of the beholder, then, isn’t it?

I admit to being something of a stickler about this topic. I bring it up over and over again. And the reason?

I believe that our villains are, for the most part, cardboard cutouts or childish actors on a makeshift stage. Why? Because—for the most part—we do not give them sufficient reason for the acts the do. Worse, we often claim that their actions are “just because they’re evil”.

In the past I’ve warned that even mass-murderers had a mother. Most were loved as children. Most, at one time or another, dreamed about a bright future.

Something changed those dreams. Something moved the wide-eyed innocence of a child into darker realms, and it is that journey that defines the villains in your story. At least it does if your villain is to be believed.

Today’s challenge: Create on a notepad, or even in your mind, a bad guy who has had a good family, true love, dreams and aspirations. Create a villain that has sorrow in his or her heart, and who has suffered great loss. Find it in yourself to make a villain that has friends who really care for him (or her).

Today’s challenge is to find a way to create a villain who’s defeat (if defeat there will be), will be more than just a “Hah, vile scum, eat flaming death!”

I challenge you to create a human villain.

http://uphillwriting.org/2010/07/27/the-evil-that-men-do/

Advertisements

18 Comments Add yours

  1. lulekisizwe says:

    Hmmm, yeah, evil is a realtive term!

    Interesting challenge… will have to think about that a bit ;}

    1. theonlycin says:

      The evil you have to confront in your efforts to curb that awful violence against women cannot ever be humanised!

      1. lulekisizwe says:

        i agree, so i guess i don’t need to create a villain, there are already enough ;}

  2. Paula says:

    I posted a comment on the UW site. Thanks for this post!

    1. theonlycin says:

      You’re welcome Paula.

  3. colonialist says:

    Everyone has elements of good and evil. The villains allow the evil to outweigh, and ultimately submerge, the good. At that stage I can’t believe it achieves anything to point out what a lovable child he or she may have been, or that charisma retains the loyalty of some misguided admirers.

    1. theonlycin says:

      Col, I think what Rik is trying to point out here is the cases where the evil is not ‘allowed’ in as much as it is a gradual corrosion. It’s not an easy challenge, give it a go?

      1. colonialist says:

        I see what you mean.

        No, it isn’t easy.

  4. halfp1nt says:

    Interesting challenge.

    1. theonlycin says:

      Going to think about it Shorty?

  5. Kavita says:

    A very thought provoking read, Cindy!
    I believe Evil only exists in the mind of the one making the judgement! Cuz for all we know, for the one committing the so-called “evil act”, it could be the fairest thing to do!
    We are into the habit of attaching meaning and definition to words as per our convenience… “subjectivity” exists for a purpose! Who knows what mental state the perpetrator was in when he did whatever he did! Who knows if he is mentally challenged! Who knows what he had had to go through for him to react in such a manner! Questions whose answers will probably give a better insight on “evil” ..
    For the challenge you’ve posed:
    My villain – that office worker who wants a promotion so badly to support his family, that he is ready to step over and backstab his peers! You say I am crazy?!?! Hmm.. think about…
    He gets his promotion. He is now vile (according to his peer), but more importantly, in his own eyes. So… was the promotion his victory, or defeat?!
    An excellent post, Cindy!!!! Thanks for sharing such a deep thought…

    1. theonlycin says:

      You’re far from crazy!

      1. Kavita says:

        yea..right! I’m crazier! 😉

  6. buttercup600 says:

    Very thought provoking and I guess I’ll have to think about this…not an easy task my dear friend but very interesting 🙂 Sweet dreams oxo

    1. theonlycin says:

      Not an easy task at all. Ek het my eintlik dood gegril!

  7. Emery Herz says:

    What i discover difficult is to discover a blog that may capture me for a minute but your blog is different. Bravo.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s